Why do Boards fail?

Reflecting on some spectacular corporate governance failures, Bridget Biggar argues that it is time to put boards under the same performance criteria as other management teams

A litany of recent corporate governance failures suggest that there appears to be a problem with how many of the largest businesses are run - Kraft’s botched takeover of Cadbury’s, the Prudential’s failed bid for AIG at a cost of $450m, BA’s failure to deal with a longstanding employee relations issue, BP’s failure to deal with the biggest ever environmental disaster in North America, and the meltdown of the financial system.

The common theme that underpins these corporate fiascos is a failure of corporate governance controls. It’s becoming evident that something needs to change.

With recent corporate behaviours looking anything but responsible or sustainable, many chief executives, especially in the banking world, recognised they need to rebuild trust and restore confidence in their businesses. While there have been changes in a number of chairman and CEO roles in the financial services sector, notably at Royal Bank of Scotland and Northern Rock, there has not been a significant shake up in board membership across industry.

In a withering attack, a New York commentator described UK boards as the most incestuous in the developed world. While the criticism might be overdone, it is perhaps surprising that we haven’t seen a greater shake-up of board level appointments in the last year. In a McKinsey survey released in Spring 2010, out of 186 directors questioned, only half thought their boards had met the corporate stress test of the downturn. In other words there is a fundamental lack of faith on the part of executives who have to run the business in the non-executives who are supposed to steward the business.

At the heart of the problem, there appears to be a tendency to reward well deserving colleagues and acquaintances with a seat on the board without scrutinising whether they are the right people for the job. The government tried to encourage a shake-up of boardrooms when it launched the Higgs Review in 2002. Higgs advised there needed to be greater representation of all aspects of commercial life in the boardrooms and to draw on a much bigger talent pool. The impression is that fundamental change to board make-up (e.g. more women, more ethnic minorities etc) is not happening.

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has recently undertaken a review of corporate standards for listed companies and it published its recommendations in May. It had four clear recommendations for board members:

  • To increase accountability, all directors of FTSE 350 companies should be put forward for re-election every year.
  • To promote proper debate in the boardroom, there are new principles for the leadership of the chairman, the responsibility of the non-executive directors to provide constructive challenge, and the time commitment expected of all directors.
  • To encourage boards to be well balanced and avoid groupthink, there are new principles for the composition and selection of the board, including the need to appoint members on merit, against objective criteria, and with due regard for the benefits of diversity, including gender diversity.
  • To help enhance the board’s performance and awareness of its strengths and weaknesses, the chairman should hold regular development reviews with each director and FTSE 350 companies should have externally facilitated board effectiveness reviews at least every three years.

These are eminently sensible guidelines but long overdue. Some recent examples such as Prudential’s failed AIG bid and BA's long simmering industrial relations problem appear to be subject to what the FRC calls groupthink. In other words, there’s been a lack of voice amongst boards to properly challenge and hold account the executive on its strategy.

Surely, it has to be the case that if management is subject to performance reviews, it’s important to know the board is fit for purpose as well, particularly in times of crisis. Great talent can be brought in to an organisation and add great value, but the FRC’s report infers that all too often board members are not being appointed based on the right criteria - in other words is a pharmaceutical boss the best candidate for the chairmanship of a bank? And if he is the right man for the job, how can his board be judged on performance without some formal review or assessment? Without the board being assessed, it’s difficult to understand how they can then make a judgement about the performance of a management team.

Leadership is fundamental to the success of a business and successful leadership comes from the top. The board cannot expect senior management to improve its game, especially in these economically challenging times, without first asking itself some searching questions.

Bridget Biggar is director of HR at consulting firm Management Intelligence.

For more information, videos and advice for SMEs, visit www.freshbusinessthinking.com

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

The 50 Best beachwear

The 50 Best beachwear

The hottest summer gear for men and women
Still standing: George Galloway reveals why his staunchly Leftist outlook is still invariably right

Still standing: George Galloway

Written off, ridiculed, wrongly accused of taking bribes the honourable member for Bradford West, has never bowed to the critics.
How will Daniel Radcliffe's fans react to his latest turn - as a damaged, drug-taking Beatnik poet?

Daniel Radcliffe as drug-taking Beatnik poet

His decade as the boy wizard may be over, but that hasn't hexed Daniel Radcliffe's enchanted life.
For whom the bell tolls: £20m 'Memo' project takes shape on Dorset's Jurassic coast

'Memo' project takes shape on Dorset coast

It started as a stonemason's visionary idea – to commemorate all the species that have ever existed and are now extinct.
Just add sunshine: Bill Granger's Turkish delights

Just add sunshine: Bill Granger's Turkish delights

Turkish cuisine is perfect for those long, sociable weekend meals with friends. It's just a shame that money can't buy the key ingredient.
Objets czar: David Usborne’s collection of myriad objects is quite the mystery

Objets czar: David Usborne’s collection of myriad objects

To others, they're junk. To David Usborne, they are his life: useful gizmos, mysterious thingamajigs and anonymous articles that dominate his home.
The iron ore lady: Why the world's richest woman is mired in controversy

World's richest woman: Gina Rinehart

Family feuds, attempts to control the Australian media and bitter public disputes are keeping the mining magnate in the headlines.
We just click: How Lego keeps building on its success

How Lego keeps building on its success

This year, Lego announced record profits. Gerard Gilbert visits its Denmark HQ.
The other bits: Mark Hix creates delicious and economical meals with cheaper cuts of meat

Mark Hix cooks with cheaper cuts of meat

Our chef creates delicious and economical meals on a budget
Strokes of genius: How to create summer's bold make-up look

Strokes of genius: Summer's bold make-up

From coral lips to fly-away fringes, make-up artist Kim Brown and hair stylist Richard Scorer reveal how to create the look
Marking his territory: Kilian Hennessy creates fragrances designed to provoke the senses

Marking his territory: Kilian Hennessy

The perfumer creates fragrances designed to provoke the senses
Photo essay: Britain's 1948 Olympians today

Britain's 1948 Olympians today

Photo essay
The top five E3 2012 triumphs: From Ubisoft's suite of titles to Dishonored and The Last of Us

The top five E3 2012 triumphs

The games and moments that left us grinning like the Cheshire Cat
The green movement at 50: Can the world be saved?

Can the world be saved?

Population growth and climate change are the big problems facing the earth in the next 50 years. But are there any solutions?
France: Will xenophobia go mainstream?

France: Will xenophobia go mainstream?

In the beautiful Rhone delta, John Lichfield visits a village where a dangerous new political landscape is taking shape